 |
|
|
The Human Rights Case Against Attacking Iran
Posted by: Mike_Wallace on http://PEJ.org Monday, February 07, 2005 - 10:01 PM
5574 Reads
|
|
|
| |
Respect for human rights in any country must spring forth through the will of the people and as part of a genuine democratic process. Such respect can never be imposed by foreign military might and coercion.
The Human Rights Case Against Attacking Iran
By SHIRIN EBADI and HADI GHAEMI
The New York Times
February 8, 2005
During her tour of Europe, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice has given assurances that a military attack by the United States on Iran "is simply not on the agenda at this point." But notwithstanding Ms. Rice's disavowal, recent statements by the Bush administration, starting with President Bush's State of the Union address and Vice President Dick Cheney's comments about a possible Israeli military attack on Iran, are reminiscent of the rhetoric in the months leading up to the invasion of Iraq in 2003. And Ms. Rice herself made clear that "the Iranian regime's human rights behavior and its behavior toward its own population is something to be loathed."
American policy toward the Middle East, and Iran in particular, is often couched in the language of promoting human rights. No one would deny the importance of that goal. But for human rights defenders in Iran, the possibility of a foreign military attack on their country represents an utter disaster for their cause.
The situation for human rights in Iran is far from ideal. Security forces harass, imprison and even torture human rights defenders and civil society activists. The authorities attack journalists and writers for expressing their opinions and regularly shut down newspapers. Political prisoners languish in jails.
Superfluous judicial summonses are routinely used to intimidate critics, and arbitrary detentions are common.
But Iranian society has refused to be coerced into silence. The human rights discourse is alive and well at the grassroots level; civil society activists consider it to be the most potent framework for achieving sustainable democratic reforms and political pluralism.
Indeed, American readers might be surprised to know how vigorous Iran's human rights organizations are. Last fall, when security forces unlawfully detained more than 20 young journalists and bloggers because of what they had written, independent Iranian organizations like the Center for Defense of Human Rights, the Association of Journalists for Freedom of Press, and the Students Association for Human Rights campaigned for their release.
This outcry, in tandem with support from the international community and human rights organizations like Human Rights Watch, led to the release of detainees. In fact, so great was the criticism of the abuses committed during these detentions that some of Iran's most senior government officials came out in favor of releasing the detainees.
Independent organizations are essential for fostering the culture of human rights in Iran. But the threat of foreign military intervention will provide a powerful excuse for authoritarian elements to uproot these groups and put an end to their growth.
Human rights violators will use this opportunity to silence their critics by labeling them as the enemy's fifth column. In 1980, after Saddam Hussein invaded Iran and inflamed nationalist passions, Iranian authorities used such arguments to suppress dissidents.
American hypocrisy doesn't help, either. Given the longstanding willingness of the American government to overlook abuses of human rights, particularly women's rights, by close allies in the Middle East like Saudi Arabia, it is hard not to see the Bush administration's focus on human rights violations in Iran as a cloak for its larger strategic interests.
Respect for human rights in any country must spring forth through the will of the people and as part of a genuine democratic process. Such respect can never be imposed by foreign military might and coercion - an approach that abounds in contradictions. Not only would a foreign invasion of Iran vitiate popular support for human rights activism, but by destroying civilian lives, institutions and infrastructure, war would also usher in chaos and instability. Respect for human rights is likely to be among the first casualties.
Instead, the most effective way to promote human rights in Iran is to provide moral support and international recognition to independent human rights defenders and to insist that Iran adhere to the international human rights laws and conventions that it has signed. Getting the Iranian government to abide by these international standards is the human rights movement's highest goal; foreign military intervention in Iran is the surest way to harm us and keep that goal out of reach.
Shirin Ebadi, the 2003 winner of the Nobel Peace Prize, is the founder of the Center for Defense of Human Rights in Tehran, Iran. Hadi Ghaemi is a researcher for Human Rights Watch.
Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company
Stay informed.Subscribe and get the best of PEJ News by email. Free.Prometheus Institute does not endorse any article or comment that is published on PEJ.org. The opinions expressed in all articles and comments are those of the authors and not of Prometheus Institute or the Peace, Earth & Justice News.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Say No To Tankers
Help protect the coast of BC's
Great Bear Rainforest
from the threat of oil spill
|
Past Articles
| Sunday, August 22 |
| · | Daring to object: Iraq war resisters, though often veterans themselves, have been met with a cool reception, much different from the draft dodgers of the 1960s |
| Saturday, August 21 |
| · | Uphold the Rights of the MV Sun Sea Migrants |
| · | Minister tasked with saving US airbase at the cost of the displacement of thousands |
| Thursday, August 19 |
| · | Myths and Realities about 490 Tamil Refugees on MV Sun Sea |
| Wednesday, August 18 |
| · | Coalition Calls for the Halt of Radioactive Steam Generator Shipment |
| Tuesday, August 17 |
| · | The Guns of August Lowering the Flag on the American Century |
| · | Climate Change Debate Rises with Pakistan Floods |
| Monday, August 16 |
| · | Radioactive Waste Gradually Disseminated into Everyday Items |
| · | The proposals of “Peoples Agreement” in the texts for the UN negotiations on climate change |
| Friday, August 13 |
| · | The Gulf at the Gas StationCan We Calculate the True Cost of Our Dependence on Oil? |
| · | Clicktivism is ruining leftist activism |
| Wednesday, August 11 |
| · | Mosque Mania Anti-Muslim Fears and the Far Right |
| Monday, August 09 |
| · | press conference by Ambassador Pablo Solon of the Plurinational State of Bolivia at the UNFCCC climate negotiations in Bonn, Germany (via UNFCCC website) |
| · | Bring Water Into Climate Change Negotiations |
| · | COP16 Mexico: Governments Must not err as thy did at COP15 in Copenhagen |
| Friday, August 06 |
| · | A Nuclear Gamble on the Not-So-Distant Horizon |
| · | Hiroshima-Nagasaki remembered: |
| Thursday, August 05 |
| · | Ecuador Signs Deal Not to Drill in Amazon Nature Reserve |
| Wednesday, August 04 |
| · | Encourage Rainforest Action Network’s New Leader to Work to End Primary Forest Logging |
| Monday, August 02 |
| · | Long-Awaited Cluster Bomb Ban Enters Into Force |
| · | Tomgram: Ann Jones, In Bed With the U.S. Army |
| Thursday, July 29 |
| · | U.N. Declares Water and Sanitation a Basic Human Right |
| · | The End of (Military) History? The United States, Israel, and the Failure of the Western Way of War |
| Wednesday, July 28 |
| · | Dennis Kucinich: WikiLeaks gave us 92,000 reasons to leave Afghanistan PICK ONE! |
| · | ENBRIDGE: NO PIPELINE, NO TANKERS. |
| · | The Human Right to Water and Sanitation” |
| · | Discurso “Derecho humano al agua y saneamiento” |
| Tuesday, July 27 |
| · | Tuesday Vote Expected on War Escalation Funding |
| Sunday, July 25 |
| · | Venezuela Will Suspend Oil Shipments to U.S. if Attacked |
| · | U.S. Labor Fights Back |
| · | RE: House Republicans and H. Res 1553 |
| · | Fallujah children's 'genetic damage' |
| Tuesday, July 20 |
| · | 18TH ANNUAL FIESTA CUBANA |
| · | U.N.'s Big Five Facilitate Arms Transfers to Rights Violators |
| Sunday, July 18 |
| · | Big Oil Makes War on the Earth The Gulf Coast Joins an Oil-Soiled Planet |
| Friday, July 16 |
| · | Water as Human Right Threatens to Split World Body |
| Thursday, July 15 |
| · | BP Caps Horizon well, or Did They? |
| · | Why Are We in Afghanistan?As Petraeus Takes Over, Could Success Be Worse Than Failure? |
| Thursday, July 08 |
| · | David Johnston by accepting this Appointment as Governor General has compromised himself |
| · | Hope and Change Fade, but War Endures Seven Reasons Why We Can’t Stop Making War |
| Tuesday, July 06 |
| · | 'Save Us From These Bankers, Fast' |
| · | Stage-Managing the War on Terror |
| Monday, July 05 |
| · | Voices from Toronto—proud to be Canadian eh! |
| Sunday, July 04 |
| · | Fourth of July 2010 Independence Day: the US –a system too entrenched to CHANGE |
| Saturday, July 03 |
| · | Obama's New Iran Sanctions: An Act of War |
| Friday, July 02 |
| · | The Land Where Theories of Warfare Go to Die |
| · | U.N. Clears Final Hurdle to Create New Gender Entity |
| Thursday, July 01 |
| · | Toronto Appeal: No More Police State Tactics! |
| · | Canada Day 2010 : 100 Reasons to Not Celebrate |
| Tuesday, June 29 |
| · | Imminent Canada-India nuclear pact heightens tensions |
| | Older Articles |
|
|
