Peace, Earth & Justice News - PEJ News
 PEJ News Home - Peace | Earth | Justice | Events | Blogs - Feb 09, 2010 @ 07:09 AM - International | USA | Canada | BC | Victoria | Vancouver    
Main Menu
· About PEJ News
· PEJ Radio
· PEJ Video
· Archives to 1996
· World Chat
· Contact-Volunteer
· Donate-Advertise
· Email Subscribe
· Fair Use Notice
· Feeds: RSS XML
· Links for PEJ
· Recommend Us
· Search Advanced
· Second Life
· Statistics PEJ.org
· Top Stories - Index
Great Sites
Currently Online
There are 230 guests and 0 members on PEJ.org right now.

Welcome Guest. Sign in to submit news or comment.

Login
 Username
 Password
 Remember me


 Log in Problems?
 New User? Sign Up!
Top PEJ Headlines
EU Commission must end forcing biodiesel from palm oil on EU countries.
NATO operation Moshtarak .... Orwell is ever present in Afghanistan ---Peace is war.
Rest in Peace, Freya Milne
Dick Cheney’s message has been received: Saudi Arabia and Israel prepare for Nuclear War while Iran tries to broker peace
Tomgram: Pratap Chatterjee, Destabilizing Pakistan
Protest tht Olympic Torch as it Parades through Vancouver's City Streets.
What An Attack on Iran Really Means: Gwynne Dyer’s Secret
The Brothel Project Review
Muslim-American political cartoonist weighs in on Danish caricatures controversy
Peace, Earth and Justice TV - PEJ Television
Paying for the Crime: Poison Legacy in Vietnam
PEJ Radio News - Free
Animal tests: A choice we can’t live with
More Info on Gordo's Dreadful Bill 30
Time to Donate to PEJ News or Advertise?
Hey! Here's a Job For You!
VANOC (Vancouver Organizing Committee for the 2010 Olympic) Evicted from Office in Victoria
The wrong message is communicated through the 2010 Olympics in Vancouver
Scientists create cells that can harness sun's rays
Tories to hire "green" adviser: let's all apply
Is there a way to wash the pesticides off fruits and vegetables before we eat them?
How Did an Idealistic President Become a Champion of Nuclear Power and By Default, Weapons Proliferation?
Torture Never Stopped Under Obama
Climate Change/ Quebec continues to shame Ottawa: Canada has become an International Pariah
Foreign News Channels Drawing U.S Viewers
The Purposes of Prometheus Institute
Is Contempt of Parliament and Parliamentary Committees “sufficient cause” for suspending, removing or jailing Harper and impugned ministers?
Who's Who - Contact Peace, Earth & Justice News Volunteers
Stop carping: Fish farms are the real problem
Harper, and his regressive policies on climate change, are even out of sync with the World Economic Forum
The Coming U.S. Budget Attack
Have a Koch and a Smile
Links for Peace, Earth & Justice
Climate Action Network undermines strong resolve of developing states
A Complementary Solution for Production of Medical Isotope
Saving the planet one meal at a time
Obama Provokes War Against China and Iran
Bolivia says: The Copenhagen accord will cause the temperature to rise to between 3º and 4º C
Do Harper’s Christian Evangelical beliefs explain his unconditional support on Israel?
Mining our own business: Canada’s secret war
Tories stand pat on Omar Khadr
Parents Beware: Hermit Crabs Make Bad Pets
Spanish judge to probe Guantanamo Torture claims
Is Canada Guilty of Climate Negligence?
US interpretation of Article 13 of UN Security Council Resolution 1441 may have influenced Goldsmith
PEJ News Feeds - RSS, Atom, XML and AvantGo for PDA
Terrorism Soft and Hard, Big and Small
Local Leaders Shut Out of Military-Run Relief Efforts in Haiti
Dolphins in tanks: Cruel confinement
A Global Push for Clean Energy: The International Renewable Energy A Global Push for Clean Energy: The International Renewable Energy
 
spacer.gif
spacer.gif   Internal CIA Report Shows Agents Tortured, Killed Prisoners
Posted by: shamuscook on http://PEJ.org Tuesday, August 25, 2009 - 06:02 PM
1860 Reads
  spacer.gif
 
Peace News
Internal CIA Report Shows Agents Tortured, Killed Prisoners

PEJ News - Tom Eley -
On Monday, the White House made public a heavily redacted version of a Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) inspector general’s report discussing cases of agency torture and murder of prisoners in Iraq and Afghanistan. The same day, Attorney General Eric Holder appointed a federal prosecutor to investigate nearly a dozen cases of torture discussed in the report.

www.wsws.org


Separately, an anonymous White House official told the media that the US would continue the practice of rendition, whereby terror suspects are abducted and sent to other nations to be interrogated under torture.

The 159-page report was produced more than five years ago, in May of 2004, but had been suppressed by both the Bush and Obama administrations. Its release was forced by a court order, which came in response to a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit filed by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU).

The New York Times reports that “two dozen abuse cases” were brought to the attention of the Bush Justice Department in the report years ago. Charges were never brought in these cases, in which “some detainees died and others suffered serious abuses.”

Among the known cases of CIA-US military torture discussed in the full report is the murder of Manadel al-Jamadi, an Iraqi who was captured by Navy Seals in 2003. He was evidently beaten on his arrest, and then taken naked and hooded to Abu Ghraib prison where a CIA interrogator, Mark Swanner, ordered him suspended from a barred window by his arms, which were tied behind his back.

Al-Jamadi died either as a result of the beating he received at the hands of the Seals or from his CIA interrogation. Charles Graner and other US Army reservists then infamously posed for photographs over the man’s corpse. While Graner was eventually convicted for his role in prisoner abuse at Abu Ghraib, neither Swanner or the Navy Seal commander who ordered and oversaw al-Jamadi’s arrest and torture have been punished.

There are a number of clear cases of abuse and torture documented in the unredacted sections of the report:

* An agent told a suspect that his mother would be raped in front of him.

* To induce fear, on more than one occasion CIA agents simulated the killing of inmates in adjoining rooms by firing a gun, the report reveals. Both US and international law make illegal, and define as torture, threats made on the life of a prisoner.

* An interrogator told Khalid Sheikh Mohammed that if another terrorist attack took place in the United States, “We’re going to kill your children.”

* An interrogator pinched the carotid artery of a prisoner until he lost consciousness, and then shook him awake, repeating the process two more times.

* CIA agents threatened to use a power drill on Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, who is accused of participating in the bombing of the USS Cole in October of 2000. Agents also threatened to shoot him with a handgun.

Al-Nashiri was also the subject of repeated waterboarding. According to a 2006 Red Cross report leaked earlier in the year, Nashiri reported that agents threatened him with “sodomy, and the arrest and rape of his family.”

An entire chapter of the report is redacted, including its title. Given its location between two sections detailing forms of torture used in interrogations, it may well refer to particularly brutal, and even fatal, cases.

The inspector general’s report does not delve into cases of torture at CIA prison “black sites” that were secretly established in a number of countries after the US invasion of Afghanistan in 2001.

The methods described in the inspector general’s report went beyond even the forms of torture authorized by Bush administration legal memos produced by Justice Department lawyers in 2002 and 2005. These memos were released by the Obama administration earlier in the year, also in response to a Freedom of Information suit by the ACLU. One purpose of the report appears to have been to analyze discrepancies between those forms of torture formally authorized by the Bush administration and what was actually taking place in the field.

The report also illustrates that CIA officials were aware that the methods used by their personnel could place them in legal jeopardy, noting that “the agency faces potentially serious long-term political and legal challenges as a result of the... program, particularly its use of [enhanced interrogation techniques] and the inability of the US Government to decide what it will ultimately do with terrorists detained by the agency.” The report states further that “public revelation” could “seriously damage... the reputation and effectiveness of the agency itself.”

Late Monday afternoon, Holder announced the appointment of John Durham, a federal prosecutor from Connecticut, to investigate a number of cases included in the inspector general’s report that had been brought to the attention of the Bush administration. In a separate inquiry, Durham is investigating whether the CIA broke the law by destroying video footage of interrogation sessions with prisoners—footage which likely featured methods of torture.

Also on Monday, Obama administration officials, speaking on condition of anonymity, said that the White House had formally decided to carry on with the policy of rendition. The administration would give a greater role to State Department diplomats in overseeing the fate of rendered prisoners, administration sources said.

Civil liberties groups were quick to condemn the decision. Amrit Singh of the ACLU pointed out that the sort of diplomatic access to prisoners promised by Obama had done little in the past to ease the plight of those rendered to third countries, pointing to the case of Canadian Maher Arar, who was tortured in Syria for an extended period in spite of several visits from a Canadian diplomat.

With the court-ordered release of the CIA inspector general’s report, the Obama administration turned its attention to damage control, with Obama announcing the creation of a new White House task force to oversee the interrogation of “high value detainees” and Attorney General Holder announcing the appointment of a prosecutor to reopen a handful of torture cases.

Obama distanced himself from the Justice Department decision. Deputy Press Secretary Bill Burton said Obama, now on vacation in Martha’s Vineyard, believes “we should be looking forward, not backward,” and that Holder “ultimately is going to make the decisions.”

Since the Bush Justice Department torture memos were made public in April, Obama has repeatedly promised that there would be no investigations, much less prosecutions, of high-ranking officials from the previous administration. If Holder’s investigation goes forward, it is probable that it will focus on supposed “rogue” agents in the field, in spite of the now overwhelming evidence that torture was systemic and organized and approved by the upper echelons of the Bush White House.

The military-intelligence apparatus lobbied against the CIA inspector general report’s release, even though such a move would have defied a court order and basic democratic precepts such as the separation of powers.

There appear to be sharp divisions within the Obama administration over how to respond to the report’s publication, with the CIA openly opposing the Justice Department’s reopening of any cases. “Justice has had the complete document since 2004, and their career prosecutors have reviewed it carefully for legal accountability,” said CIA spokesman Paul Gimigliano. “That’s already been done.”

In a Monday email to CIA employees, Director Leon Panetta defended the agency—and torture. “[T]his much is clear,” Panetta wrote. “The CIA obtained intelligence from high-value detainees when inside information on Al Qa’ida was in short supply. Whether this was the only way to obtain that information will remain a legitimate area of dispute, with Americans holding a range of views on the methods used.”

The new interrogation unit announced by the administration, dubbed the High-Value Detainee Interrogation Group (HIG), will be overseen by the National Security Council, the top presidential military-foreign policy body.

It appears that HIG will oversee a panoply of spy agencies, domestic and international, engaged in interrogations. It will include at least the CIA and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). Deputy White House Press Secretary Burton told the media the authority will bring “all these different elements under one group,” and will be based at FBI headquarters in Washington and led by an FBI official.

The creation of a White House interrogation authority is typical of Obama’s moves in “the war on terror” since his inauguration. The president makes high publicity announcements, creates task forces, etc., to give the appearance of “change.” In reality, his measures create a new institutional and legal framework to continue the Bush administration’s criminal policies of torture, kidnapping, domestic spying and indefinite detention.

The entire political establishment is implicated in the anti-democratic practices of the “war on terror,” including the torture and murders carried out by the CIA. Leading congressmen and senators of both parties were given copies of the inspector general’s report shortly after it was produced five years ago, and it was shown to all of the members of the House and Senate intelligence committees in September of 2006.

Leading Democrats joined with Republicans to suppress the report and conceal its findings from the public.

Torture and other violations of basic democratic rights arise inevitably from a militaristic policy based on the launching of wars of aggression. The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq—for which 9/11 served as the pretext—enjoyed broad bipartisan support and the enthusiastic backing of the American media.

The Nuremberg trial of Nazi war criminals concluded that the launching of aggressive war was “the supreme international crime, differing only from other war crimes in that it contains within itself the accumulated evil of the whole.”

There must be a full accounting of the illegal methods used by the US military and spy agencies in “the war on terror.” Those policy-makers responsible, from Bush on down, must be subjected to criminal prosecution. This, however, cannot be achieved by appealing to the political parties and institutions of the ruling elite, all of which are implicated in the crimes of American imperialism.

A thorough accounting—and the prevention of further abuses—requires the independent mobilization of the working class.


Stay informed.Subscribe and get the best of PEJ News by email. Free.

Prometheus Institute does not endorse any article or comment that is published on PEJ.org. The opinions expressed in all articles and comments are those of the authors and not of Prometheus Institute or the Peace, Earth & Justice News.


 
spacer.gif
spacer.gif spacer.gif spacer.gif spacer.gif
Search PEJ.org
 

Peace, Earth & Justice News - PEJ News

Over 500,000
Pages Viewed
Every Month

Advertise
Support PEJ News

Prometheus Institute

PEJ.org   info@pej.ca
Box 8307
Victoria BC
V8W 3R9 Canada
Past Articles
Friday, February 05
·Chevron Facing Free Speech Problems In U.S. Over Defense of $27 Billion Ecuador Lawsuit 
Thursday, February 04
·China's Slave Wages For U.S. Workers 
·Do Harper’s Christian Evangelical beliefs explain his unconditional support on Israel? 
·European Firms See Windfall in Renewable Energy 
Wednesday, February 03
·Hyper-militarisation of development assistance to Haiti. 
·How Did an Idealistic President Become a Champion of Nuclear Power and By Default, Weapons Proliferation? 
·Climate Change/ Quebec continues to shame Ottawa: Canada has become an International Pariah 
·Tories stand pat on Omar Khadr 
·Is Canada Guilty of Climate Negligence? 
·Rest in Peace, Freya Milne 
Tuesday, February 02
·Obama Provokes War Against China and Iran 
·The Drone Surge: Today, Tomorrow, and 2047 
·Spanish judge to probe Guantanamo Torture claims 
Monday, February 01
·A Global Push for Clean Energy: The International Renewable Energy A Global Push for Clean Energy: The International Renewable Energy 
·Campaign to confront corporate divine right to rule 
·Foreign News Channels Drawing U.S Viewers 
Sunday, January 31
· A Complementary Solution for Production of Medical Isotope 
·Dolphins in tanks: Cruel confinement 
Saturday, January 30
·Climate Action Network undermines strong resolve of developing states 
·Harper, and his regressive policies on climate change, are even out of sync with the World Economic Forum 
·Local Leaders Shut Out of Military-Run Relief Efforts in Haiti 
Friday, January 29
·Pacific Islanders & climate change: leading the fight, feeling the heat 
·Blair’s interrogation before Chilcot Inquiry into the Iraq war: no matter what Blair says; the invasion was an illegal act 
Thursday, January 28
·Sued by the forest: Should nature be able to take you to court? 
·Vandenberg Missile Test: "Dangerous, Destabilizing and Provocative". 
·Public not Private Procurement for Sewage treatment in the Capital Region District Victoria B.C. 
·US interpretation of Article 13 of UN Security Council Resolution 1441 may have influenced Goldsmith 
Wednesday, January 27
·2010 World Economic Forum in Davos – Harper the “New Human Welfare Czar” ? 
·January 27 2010 Obama’s State of the Union Address; Change is not to do things the way they were done before 
·No more new licenses or expansion for BC fish farms 
Tuesday, January 26
·Torture Never Stopped Under Obama 
·January 21, 2010 Supreme Court decision on corporate “rights” also ignores international consequences 
·Forsey offers "Prorogation Questions & Answers" 
·Uvic Exhibit And Film Events Jan 26, 2010 
Monday, January 25
·World Social Forum 2010 | Urgent Need to Revisit Article 6 of World Social Forum Charter 
·Parliament Locked; Opposition Parties are ready for work: Parliament must be Summoned. 
·Grassroots Communities Mining Mini-Grant Program 
Saturday, January 23
·Canadians Against Proroguing Parliament (CAPP) Rallies across Canada: We’re not Going to take This Any more 
·Supreme Court Corporation Madness 
·Governments Are Corrupting Climate Data 
Friday, January 22
·End Prorogue of Canada's Federal Parliament 
·Happy anniversary of Roe v. Wade! January 22 
·Nuclear ‘Renaissance’ or ‘Retreat’? France is not the Example 
·No Island Light Rail 
·Left Coast Events - Jan 2010 
Thursday, January 21
·Change war resister rules, MP urges 
·US Department of Defense “Clarifies” Doctrine on Psychological Operations 
Wednesday, January 20
·A Mockery of Justice: Conservatives should be prosecuted not rewarded for their violation of the Elections Act. 
· Mining our own business: Canada’s secret war 
Related links
· More about Peace News
· News by shamuscook


Most read story in Peace News:
Terrorism Soft and Hard, Big and Small

Stories, Features, Opinion and Analysis :: Peace, Earth & Justice News   

PEJ News-- This free service serves up daily news, opinion and analysis of peace, environment and justice issues. Stay informed with web and email stories often days, weeks and months ahead of the mainstream media. Peace, Earth & Justice News is produced entirely by volunteers and is a project of the non-profit Prometheus Institute based in Victoria, Canada.

PEJ.org-- is a project of Prometheus Institute.  Prometheus Institute does not endorse any article or comment that is published on PEJ.org. The opinions expressed in all articles and comments are those of the authors and not of Prometheus Institute or the Peace, Earth & Justice News 

PEJ.org  - Founder Al Rycroft
Who's Who Volunteers
Webmaster: freshchange[at]gmail.com

 PEJ News Home -- Peace News | Environment News | Justice News | PEJ Calendar of Events | PEJ Blogs -- World News | US News | Canadian News | British Columbian - BC News | Victoria and Island News | Vancouver and Lower Mainland News

About PEJ.org | My AccountPEJ News Archives | AvantGo Feed - Atom Feed | Banner and Link Ads AvailableChat Around the World | Contact our Volunteers | Copyright Information | Donations Online | Email Subscriptions or New SubscriberFair Dealing and Fair Use Notice | Index of all News | Login Sign InLogout Logoff |  PEJ Links | Public Domain | Recommend Us To A Friend | Register New UserRSS Feed | Search Advanced | Submit News Must First Login or Register | Subscriptions by Email or New SubscriberTraffic Stats | Volunteer with PEJ | XML Feed